Not yet under construction

It would be cool if this were a wiki where you could look up a scientific article and see what people are saying about it.

Has it failed to replicate? Has it been withdrawn? Over-hyped? Does it have statistical errors? Unjustified conclusions?

Does it make a good assignment for undergraduates? Use a cool visualization?

I would love it if this existed. Anyone want to help? Contact me.

-- Nate Kornell, Williams College